| 2011-2012 |
| Player | College |
| Taelor Higgins | | Texas A&M International University |
| Brittany Berry | | Texas Wesleyan University |
| Haley Goldwater | | University of Arkansas at Monticello |
| Taylor Jones | | Dallas Baptist University |
| 2010-2011 |
| Player | College |
| Sapphire Reid | | Long Island University |
| Lauren Ray | | Henderson State University |
| 2009-2010 |
| Player | College |
| Anissa Garcia | | University of Mary Hardin Baylor |
| Kayla Caffey | | Hannibal LaGrange College |
| Tatiana Booth | | East Central University |
| Nicole Canales | | St. Mary's University |
| Mikeya Edwards | | Grambling State University |
| Yakira Essix | | East Central University |
| Davina Hirst | | Texas Lutheran University |
| Nikki West | | Grambling State University |
| 2008-2009 |
| Player | College |
| Kayla Riggs | | University of Missouri Kansas City |
| Lauren Tharp | | Schreiner University |
| Christina Smith | | University of Texas at Tyler |
| Meghan Fichtel | | University of Texas Pan American |
| 2007-2008 |
| Player | College |
| Jessika Robinson | | Faulkner University |
| LaTanya Daniels | | Faulkner University |
| 2006-2007 |
| Player | College |
| Lindsay Ellisor | | Southeastern Oklahoma State University |
| Ashley Montalvo | | University of Texas at Tyler |
| Sileiny Arauz | | Hannibal LaGrange College |
| Katelyn Nelson | | Dixie State University |
| Tiffany Williams | | Texas College |
| 2005-2006 |
| Player | College |
| Ivana Mali | | Henderson State University |
| Amber McKinney | | Oklahoma Panhandle State University |
| Andrea Walker | | Huston-Tillotson University |
| Sheena Logan | | Texas College |
| Stephanie Lewis | | Fisk University |
