2019
| Player | College | Program |
| Maycol Reyes | University of North Carolina-Greensboro | Soccer |
| Bernabe Lopez | University of Incarnate Word | Soccer |
| Giancarlo Saldana | West Texas A&M University | Soccer |
| Tanner Clements | West Texas A&M University | Soccer |
| Ivan Franco | David & Elkins University | Soccer |
| Yaya Dosso | David & Elkins University | Soccer |
| Tanner Keough | David & Elkins University | Soccer |
| Lucas Mastrogiuseppe | Saint Leo University | Soccer |
| Misael Sanchez | East Texas Baptist University | Soccer |
| Max De Varennes | Concordia University | Soccer |
| Kevin Tiero | University of Southwest | Soccer |
| Matteo Finazzi | Dakota Wesleyan University | Soccer |
| Brenson Dunn | University of Colorado | Soccer |
2018
| Player | College | Program |
| Jacob White | St. Marys University | Soccer |
| Tom Pearson | Lake Erie College | Soccer |
| Killian Panis | Canisius College | Soccer |
| Praise Ayeni | University of the Southwest | Soccer |
| Eddie Rodriguez | Texas Wesleyan University | Soccer |
2017
| Player | College | Program |
| Eddie Dakwa | Siena College | Soccer |
| Tim Ugo | Houston Baptist University | Soccer |
| Joel Shungu | Oregon State University | Soccer |
| Thomas Moacwi | University of Mobile | Soccer |
| Josiah Bostic | American University | Soccer |
| Chandler O'Dwyer | University of Massachusetts | Soccer |
| Juan Garcia | Texas State University | Physical Therapy |
| Enrique Zuniga | West Texas A&M University | Engineering |
| Yohance Alexander | Long Island Post University | Soccer |
2016
| Player | College | Program |
| Eddie Dakwa | Siena College | Soccer |
| Tim Ugo | Siena College | Soccer |
| Joel Shungu | Oregon State University | Soccer |
| Thomas Moacwi | University of Mobile | Soccer |
| Josiah Bostic | American University | Soccer |
| Chandler O'Dwyer | University of Massachusetts | Soccer |
| Juan Garcia | Texas State University | Physical Therapy |
| Enrique Zuniga | West Texas A&M University | Engineering |
2015
| Player | College | Program |
| Eduardo Avalos | Manhattan College | Soccer |
| Steven Chavez | Texas Wesleyan University | Soccer |
|
Tyler Day |
University of Houston |
Business |
|
Tawwab Emiola |
University of San Francisco |
Soccer |
2014
| Player | College | Program |
| Josh Nieto | University of Southwest | Soccer |
| Ramiro Perez | Rogers State University | Soccer |
| Chris Escalera | Midwestern State University | Soccer |
| Frank Galicia | Texas Wesleyan Univeristy | Soccer |
| Hugo Pascencia | University of Our Lady of the Lake | Soccer |
| Reggie Gonzales | Rogers State University | Soccer |
| Jeremy Hoelzer | Rogers State University | Soccer |
| Micah Day | Texas Wesleyan University | Soccer |
| Felix Charles | University of Southwest |
Soccer |
| Damion Passos | Midwestern State University | Business |
| Carlos Aparicio-Perez | University of Colorado-Colorado Springs | Biology |
2013
| Player | College | Program |
| Max Naranjo | University of Southwest | |
| Tony Salazar | University of Southwest | Soccer |
| Jackson Weddle | Stephen F. Austin University | Business |
| Bradford Love | University of North Texas | Engineering |
| Rob Sierra | Texas State University | Business |
| Jeremiah Garcia | University of North Texas | Business |
2012
| Player | College | Program |
| Andrew Carr | University of North Texas | Engineering |
| Leevi Schwartz | Dallas Baptist University | Soccer |
| Gabe Vera | Huston Tillotson University | Soccer |
| Ebun Odubonojo | Huston Tillotson University | Soccer |
| Oscar Montalvo | Midwestern University | Biology |
| Adrian Gonzalez | University of Texas-Arlington | Graphic Design |
| Cesar Adame | Midwestern State University | Business |
| Gavin Bryant | Huston Tillotson University | Soccer |
2011
| Player | College | Program |
| Adrian Cruz | Millersville University | Soccer |
| William Taylor | Millersville University | Soccer |
| Jose Fajardo | Talladega University | Soccer |
| Pablo Gonzalez | Northwood University | Soccer |
| Nelson Gonzalez | Northwood University | Soccer |
| Joel Salinas | Mary Hardin-Baylor University | Soccer |
| Sean Jordan | Oklahoma Wesleyan University | Soccer |
| Robert Gallegos | Oklahoma Wesleyan Univeristy | Soccer |
| Peter Zuniga | Northwood University | Soccer |